How to Spot a Good Editor From a Bad One

Finding the right editor for your manuscript is kind of like dating. When you meet the right one it’s amazing – but when you pick a bad one it can spell disaster for both you and your manuscript. 

So, how can you spot a great editor from a bad one? Here are some tips for spotting a diamond editor in the rough: 

• What is the quality of writing on their website? Are there any obvious editing mistakes on their website? 

• Check their reviews – google reviews often have the most “honest” critics. 

• Do they offer deals for authors that require multiple rounds (or different levels) of editing? 

• Bad editors don’t meet deadlines or become unresponsive.  

• Good editors will be clear about what services they offer and what you should expect out of the editorial process.  

• Do they offer a free sample of their work so that you can see their level of expertise? 

• Good editors can explain their recommendations and provide you feedback to help you become a better writer. In contrast, bad editors – or bad communicators – will struggle to explain why they have edited your work, the way they have. 

A good writer-editor relationship involves some give and take. Over time, it will organically grow into a positive relationship. Ultimately, do your research and trust your gut.